The Hand You're Dealt
by Robert J. Sawyer
Copyright © 1997 by Robert J. Sawyer
All Rights Reserved

Current HUGO AWARD Finalist
For Best Short Story of the Year

Current ARTHUR ELLIS AWARD Finalist
For Best Short Story of the Year

    First published in the anthology Free Space, edited by Brad Linaweaver and 
    Edward E. Kramer (Tor, 1997). This is the author's preferred text as 
    published in the anthology Crossing the Line: Canadian Mystery Fiction With 
    A Twist, edited by Robert J. Sawyer David Skene-Melvin (Pottersfield, 1998) 

           

And ye shall know the truth, and the
truth shall make you free. -- John 8:32 

            "Got a new case for you," said my boss, Raymond Chen. "Homicide." 
            My heart started pounding. Mendelia habitat is supposed to be a 
utopia. Murder is almost unheard of here. 
            Chen was fat -- never exercised, loved rich foods. He knew his 
lifestyle would take decades off his life, but, hey, that was his choice. 
"Somebody offed a soothsayer, over in Wheel Four," he said, wheezing slightly. 
"Baranski's on the scene now." 
            My eyebrows went up. A dead soothsayer? This could be very 
interesting indeed. 

            I took my pocket forensic scanner and exited The Cop Shop. That was 
its real name -- no taxes in Mendelia, after all. You needed a cop, you hired 
one. In this case, Chen had said, we were being paid by the Soothsayers' Guild. 
That meant we could run up as big a bill as necessary -- the SG was stinking 
rich. One of the few laws in Mendelia was that everyone had to use soothsayers. 
            Mendelia consisted of five modules, each looking like a wagon wheel 
with spokes leading in to a central hub. The hubs were all joined together by a 
long axle, and separate travel tubes connected the outer edges of the wheels. 
The whole thing spun to simulate gravity out at the rims, and the travel tubes 
saved you having to go down to the zero-g of the axle to move from one wheel to 
the next. 
            The Cop Shop was in Wheel Two. All the wheel rims were hollow, with 
buildings growing up toward the axle from the outer interior wall. Plenty of 
open spaces in Mendelia -- it wouldn't be much of a utopia without those. But 
our sky was a hologram, projected on the convex inner wall of the rim, above our 
heads. The Cop Shop's entrance was right by Wheel Two's transit loop, a series 
of maglev tracks along which robocabs ran. I hailed one, flashed my debit card 
at an unblinking eye, and the cab headed out. The Carling family, who owned the 
taxi concession, was one of the oldest and richest families in Mendelia. 
            The ride took fifteen minutes. Suzanne Baranski was waiting outside 
for me. She was a good cop, but too green to handle a homicide alone. Still, 
she'd get a big cut of the fee for being the original responding officer -- 
after all, the cop who responds to a call never knows who, if anyone, is going 
to pick up the tab. When there is money to be had, first-responders get a 
disproportionate share. 
            I'd worked with Suze a couple of times before, and had even gone to 
see her play cello with the symphony once. Perfect example of what Mendelia's 
all about, that. Suze Baranski had blue-collar parents. They'd worked as welders 
on the building of Wheel Five; not the kind who'd normally send a daughter for 
music lessons. But just after she'd been born, their soothsayer had said that 
Suze had musical talent. Not enough to make a living at it -- that's why she's a 
cop by day -- but still sufficient that it would be a shame not to let her 
develop it. 
            "Hi, Toby," Suze said to me. She had short red hair and big green 
eyes, and, of course, was in plain clothes -- you wanted a uniformed cop, you 
called our competitors, Spitpolish, Inc. 
            "Howdy, Suze," I said, walking toward her. She led me over to the 
door, which had been locked off in the open position. A holographic sign next to 
it proclaimed: Skye Hissock Soothsayer Let Me Reveal Your Future! Fully 
Qualified for Infant and Adult Readings 
            We stepped into a well-appointed lobby. The art was unusual for such 
an office -- it was all original pen-and-ink political cartoons. There was 
Republic CEO Da Silva, her big nose exaggerated out of all proportion, and next 
to it, Axel Durmont, Earth's current president, half buried in legislation 
printouts and tape that doubtless would have been red had this been a color 
rendering. The artist's signature caught my eye, the name Skye with curving 
lines behind it that I realized were meant to represent clouds. Just like Suze, 
our decedent had had varied talents. 
            "The body is in the inner private office," said Suze, leading the 
way. That door, too, was already open. She stepped in first, and I followed. 
            Skye Hissock's body sat in a chair behind his desk. His head had 
been blown clean off. A great carnation bloom of blood covered most of the wall 
behind him, and chunks of brain were plastered to the wall and the credenza 
behind the desk. 
            "Christ," I said. Some utopia. 
            Suze nodded. "Blaster, obviously," she said, sounding much more 
experienced in such matters than she really was. "Probably a gigawatt charge." 
            I began looking around the room. It was opulent; old Skye had 
obviously done well for himself. Suze was poking around, too. "Hey," she said, 
after a moment. I turned to look at her. She was climbing up on the credenza. 
The blast had knocked a small piece of sculpture off the wall -- it lay in two 
pieces on the floor -- and she was examining where it had been affixed. "Thought 
that's what it was," she said, nodding. "There's a hidden camera here." 
            My heart skipped a beat. "You don't suppose he got the whole thing 
on disk, do you?" I said, moving over to where she was. I gave her a hand 
getting down off the credenza, and we opened it up -- a slightly difficult task; 
crusted blood had sealed its sliding doors. Inside was a dusty recorder unit. I 
turned to Skye's desk, and pushed the release switch to pop up his monitor 
plate. Suze pushed the recorder's playback button. As we'd suspected, the unit 
was designed to feed into the desk monitor. 
            The picture showed the reverse angle from behind Skye's desk. The 
door to the private office opened and in came a young man. He looked to be 
eighteen, meaning he was just the right age for the mandatory adult soothsaying. 
He had shoulder length dirty-blond hair, and was wearing a t-shirt imprinted 
with the logo of a popular meed. I shook my head. There hadn't been a good 
multimedia band since The Cassies, if you ask me. 
            "Hello, Dale," said what must have been Skye's voice. He spoke with 
deep, slightly nasal tones. "Thank you for coming in." 
            Okay, we had the guy's picture, and his first name, and the name of 
his favorite meed. Even if Dale's last name didn't turn up in Skye's appointment 
computer, we should have no trouble tracking him down. 
            "As you know," said Skye's recorded voice, "the law requires two 
soothsayings in each person's life. The first is done just after you're born, 
with one or both of your parents in attendance. At that time, the soothsayer 
only tells them things they'll need to know to get you through childhood. But 
when you turn eighteen, you, not your parents, become legally responsible for 
all your actions, and so it's time you heard everything. Now, do you want the 
good news or the bad news first?" 
            Here it comes, I thought. He told Dale something he didn't want to 
hear, the guy flipped, pulled out a blaster, and blew him away. 
            Dale swallowed. "The -- the good, I guess." 
            "All right," said Skye. "First, you're a bright young man -- not a 
genius, you understand, but brighter than average. Your IQ should run between 
126 and 132. You are gifted musically -- did your parents tell you that? Good. I 
hope they encouraged you." 
            "They did," said Dale, nodding. "I've had piano lessons since I was 
four." 
            "Good, good. A crime to waste such raw talent. You also have a 
particular aptitude for mathematics. That's often paired with musical ability, 
of course, so no surprises there. Your visual memory is slightly better than 
average, although your ability to do rote memorization is slightly worse. You 
would make a good long-distance runner, but ..." 
            I motioned for Suze to hit the fast-forward button; it seemed like a 
typical soothsaying, although I'd review it in depth later, if need be. Poor 
Dale fidgeted up and down in quadruple speed for a time, then Suze released the 
button. 
            "Now," said Skye's voice, "the bad news." I made an impressed face 
at Suze; she'd stopped speeding along at precisely the right moment. "I'm afraid 
there's a lot of it. Nothing devastating, but still lots of little things. You 
will begin to lose your hair around your twenty-seventh birthday, and it will 
begin to gray by the time you're thirty-two. By the age of forty, you will be 
almost completely bald, and what's left at that point will be half brown and 
half gray. 
            "On a less frivolous note, you'll also be prone to gaining weight, 
starting at about age thirty-three -- and you'll put on half a kilo a year for 
each of the following thirty years if you're not careful; by the time you're in 
your mid-fifties, that will pose a significant health hazard. You're also highly 
likely to develop adult-onset diabetes. Now, yes, that can be cured, but the 
cure is expensive, and you'll have to pay for it -- so either keep your weight 
down, which will help stave off its onset, or start saving now for the operation 
..." 
            I shrugged. Nothing worth killing a man over. Suze fast-forwarded 
the tape some more. 
            "-- and that's it," concluded Skye. "You know now everything 
significant that's coded into your DNA. Use this information wisely, and you 
should have a long, happy, healthy life." 
            Dale thanked Skye, took a printout of the information he'd just 
heard, and left. The recording stopped. It had been too much to hope for. 
Whoever killed Skye Hissock had come in after young Dale had departed. He was 
still our obvious first suspect, but unless there was something awful in the 
parts of the genetic reading we'd fast-forwarded over, there didn't seem to be 
any motive for him to kill his soothsayer. And besides, this Dale had a high IQ, 
Skye had said. Only an idiot would think there was any sense in shooting the 
messenger. 

            After we'd finished watching the recording, I did an analysis of the 
actual blaster burn. No fun, that: standing over the open top of Skye's torso. 
Most of the blood vessels had been cauterized by the charge. Still, blasters 
were only manufactured in two places I knew of -- Tokyo, on Earth, and New 
Monty. If the one used here had been made on New Monty, we'd be out of luck, but 
one of Earth's countless laws required all blasters to leave a characteristic EM 
signature, so they could be traced to their registered owners, and -- 
            Good: it was an Earth-made blaster. I recorded the signature, then 
used my compad to relay it to The Cop Shop. If Raymond Chen could find some time 
between stuffing his face, he'd send an FTL message to Earth and check the 
pattern -- assuming, of course, that the Jeffies don't scramble the message just 
for kicks. Meanwhile, I told Suze to go over Hissock's client list, while I 
started checking out his family -- fact is, even though it doesn't make much 
genetic sense, most people are killed by their own relatives. 
            Skye Hissock had been fifty-one. He'd been a soothsayer for 
twenty-three years, ever since finishing his Ph.D. in genetics. He was 
unmarried, and both his parents were long dead. But he did have a brother named 
Rodger. Rodger was married to Rebecca Connolly, and they had two children, Glen, 
who, like Dale in Skye's recording, had just turned eighteen, and Billy, who was 
eight. 
            There are no inheritance taxes in Mendelia, of course, so barring a 
will to the contrary, Hissock's estate would pass immediately to his brother. 
Normally, that'd be a good motive for murder, but Rodger Hissock and Rebecca 
Connolly were already quite rich: they owned a controlling interest in the 
company that operated Mendelia's atmosphere-recycling plant. 
            I decided to start my interviews with Rodger. Not only had brothers 
been killing each other since Cain wasted Abel, but the fingerprint lock (a 
standard ten-points-of-comparison model) on Skye's private inner office was 
programmed to recognize only four people -- Skye himself; his office cleaner, 
who Suze was going to talk to; another soothsayer named Jennifer Halasz, who 
sometimes took Skye's patients for him when he was on vacation (and who had 
called in the murder, having stopped by apparently to meet Skye for coffee); and 
dear brother Rodger. Rodger lived in Wheel Four, and worked in One. 
            I took a cab over to his office. Unlike Skye, Rodger had a real 
flesh-and-blood receptionist. Most companies that did have human receptionists 
used middle-aged, businesslike people of either sex. Some guys got so rich that 
they didn't care what people thought; they hired beautiful blonde women whose 
busts had been surgically altered far beyond what any phenotype might provide. 
But Rodger's choice was different. His receptionist was a delicate young man 
with refined, almost feminine features. He was probably older than he looked; he 
looked fourteen. 
            "Detective Toby Korsakov," I said, flashing my ID. I didn't offer to 
shake hands -- the boy looked like his would shatter if any pressure were 
applied. "I'd like to see Rodger Hissock." 
            "Do you have an appointment?" His voice was high, and there was just 
a trace of a lisp. 
            "No. But I'm sure Mr. Hissock will want to see me. It's important." 
            The boy looked very dubious, but he spoke into an intercom. "There's 
a cop here, Rodger. Says it's important." 
            There was a pause. "Send him in," said a loud voice. The boy nodded 
at me, and I walked through the heavy wooden door -- mahogany, no doubt imported 
all the way from Earth. 
            I had thought Skye Hissock's office was well-appointed, but his 
brother's put it to shame. Objets d'art from a dozen worlds were tastefully 
displayed on crystal stands. The carpet was so thick I was sure my shoes would 
sink out of sight. I walked toward the desk. Rodger rose to greet me. He was a 
muscular man, thick-necked, with lots of black hair and pale gray eyes. We shook 
hands; his grip was a show of macho strength. "Hello," he said. He boomed out 
the word, clearly a man used to commanding everyone's attention. "What can I do 
for you?" 
            "Please sit down," I said. "My name is Toby Korsakov. I'm from The 
Cop Shop, working under a contract to the Soothsayer's Guild." 
            "My God," said Rodger. "Has something happened to Skye?" 
            Although it was an unpleasant duty, there was nothing more useful in 
a murder investigation than being there to tell a suspect about the death and 
seeing his reaction. Most guilty parties played dumb far too long, so the fact 
that Rodger had quickly made the obvious connection between the SG and his 
brother made me suspect him less, not more. Still ... "I'm sorry to be the 
bearer of bad news," I said, "but I'm afraid your brother is dead." 
            Rodger's eyes went wide. "What happened?" 
            "He was murdered." 
            "Murdered," repeated Rodger, as if he'd never heard the word before. 

            "That's right. I was wondering if you knew of anyone who'd want him 
dead?" 
            "How was he killed?" asked Rodger. I was irritated that this wasn't 
an answer to my question, and even more irritated that I'd have to explain it so 
soon. More than a few homicides had been solved by a suspect mentioning the 
nature of the crime in advance of him or her supposedly having learned the 
details. "He was shot at close range by a blaster." 
            "Oh," said Rodger. He slumped in his chair. "Skye dead." His head 
shook back and forth a little. When he looked up, his gray eyes were moist. 
Whether he was faking or not, I couldn't tell. 
            "I'm sorry," I said. 
            "Do you know who did it?" 
            "Not yet. We're tracing the blaster's EM signature. But there were 
no signs of forcible entry, and, well ..." 
            "Yes?" 
            "Well, there are only four people whose fingerprints opened the door 
to Skye's inner office." 
            Rodger nodded. "Me and Skye. Who else?" 
            "His cleaner, and another soothsayer." 
            "You're checking them out?" 
            "My associate is. She's also checking all the people Skye had 
appointments with recently -- people he might have let in of his own volition." 
A pause. "Can I ask where you were this morning between ten and eleven?" 
            "Here." 
            "In your office?" 
            "That's right." 
            "Your receptionist can vouch for that?" 
            "Well ... no. No, he can't. He was out all morning. His sooth says 
he's got a facility for languages. I give him a half-day off every Wednesday to 
take French lessons." 
            "Did anyone call you while he was gone?" 
            Rodger spread his thick arms. "Oh, probably. But I never answer my 
own compad. Truth to tell, I like that half-day where I can't be reached. It 
lets me get an enormous amount of work done without being interrupted." 
            "So no one can verify your presence here?" 
            "Well, no ... no, I guess they can't. But, Crissakes, Detective, 
Skye was my brother ..." 
            "I'm not accusing you, Mr. Hissock --" 
            "Besides, if I'd taken a robocab over, there'd be a debit charge 
against my account." 
            "Unless you paid cash. Or unless you walked." You can walk down the 
travel tubes, although most people don't bother. 
            "You don't seriously believe --" 
            "I don't believe anything yet, Mr. Hissock." It was time to change 
the subject; he would be no use to me if he got too defensive. "Was your brother 
a good soothsayer?" 
            "Best there is. Hell, he read my own sooth when I turned eighteen." 
He saw my eyebrows go up. "Skye is nine years older than me; I figured, why not 
use him? He needed the business; he was just starting his practice at that 
point." 
            "Did Skye do the readings for your children, too?" 
            An odd hesitation. "Well, yeah, yeah, Skye did their infant 
readings, but Glen -- that's my oldest; just turned 18 -- he decided to go 
somewhere else for his adult reading. Waste of money, if you ask me. Skye 
would've given him a discount." 

            My compad bleeped while I was in a cab. I turned it on. 
            "Yo, Toby." Raymond Chen's fat face appeared on the screen. "We got 
the registration information on that blaster signature." 
            "Yeah?" 
            Ray smiled. "Do the words 'open-and-shut case' mean anything to you? 
The blaster belongs to one Rodger Hissock. He bought it about eleven years ago." 

            I nodded and signed off. Since the lock accepted his fingerprint, 
rich little brother would have no trouble waltzing right into big brother's 
inner office, and exploding his head. Rodger had method and he had opportunity. 
Now all I needed was to find his motive -- and for that, continuing to interview 
the family members might prove useful. 

            Eighteen-year-old Glen Hissock was studying engineering at Francis 
Crick University in Wheel Three. He was a dead ringer for his old man: built 
like a wrestler, with black hair and quicksilver eyes. But whereas father Rodger 
had a coarse, outgoing way about him -- the crusher handshake, the loud voice -- 
young Glen was withdrawn, soft-spoken, and nervous. 
            "I'm sorry about your uncle," I said, knowing that Rodger had 
already broken the news to his son. 
            Glen looked at the floor. "Me too." 
            "Did you like him?" 
            "He was okay." 
            "Just okay." 
            "Yeah." 
            "Where were you between ten and eleven this morning?" 
            "At home." 
            "Was anyone else there?" 
            "Nah. Mom and Dad were at work, and Billy -- that's my little 
brother -- was in school." He met my eyes for the first time. "Am I a suspect?" 
            He wasn't really. All the evidence seemed to point to his father. I 
shook my head in response to his question, then said, "I hear you had your sooth 
read recently." 
            "Yeah." 
            "But you didn't use your uncle." 
            "Nah." 
            "How come?" 
            A shrug. "Just felt funny, that's all. I picked a guy at random from 
the online directory." 
            "Any surprises in your sooth?" 
            The boy looked at me. "Sooth's private, man. I don't have to tell 
you that." 
            I nodded. "Sorry." 

            Two hundred years ago, in 2029, the Palo Alto Nanosystems Laboratory 
developed a molecular computer. You doubtless read about it in history class: 
during the Snow War, the U.S. used it to disassemble Bogatá atom by atom. 
            Sometimes, though, you can put the genie back in the bottle. 
Remember Hamasaki and DeJong, the two researchers at PANL who were shocked to 
see their work corrupted that way? They created and released the nano-Gorts -- 
self-replicating microscopic machines that seek out and destroy molecular 
computers, so that nothing like Bogatá could ever happen again. 
            We've got PANL nano-Gorts here, of course. They're everywhere in 
Free Space. But we've got another kind of molecular guardian, too -- inevitably, 
they were dubbed helix-Gorts. It's rumored the SG was responsible for them, but 
after a huge investigation, no indictments were ever brought. Helix-Gorts 
circumvent any attempt at artificial gene therapy. We can tell you everything 
that's written in your DNA, but we can't do a damned thing about it. Here, in 
Mendelia, you play the hand you're dealt. 

            My compad bleeped again. I switched it on. "Korsakov here." 
            Suze's face appeared on the screen. "Hi, Toby. I took a sample of 
Skye's DNA off to Rundstedt" -- a soothsayer who did forensic work for us. 
"She's finished the reading." 
            "And?" I said. 
            Suze's green eyes blinked. "Nothing stood out. Skye wouldn't have 
been a compulsive gambler, or an addict, or inclined to steal another person's 
spouse -- which eliminates several possible motives for his murder. In fact, 
Rundstedt says Skye would have had a severe aversion to confrontation." She 
sighed. "Just doesn't seem to be the kind of guy who'd end up in a situation 
where someone would want him dead." 
            I nodded. "Thanks, Suze. Any luck with Skye's clients?" 
            "I've gone through almost all the ones who'd had appointments in the 
last three days. So far, they all have solid alibis." 
            "Keep checking. I'm off to see Skye's sister-in-law, Rebecca 
Connolly. Talk to you later." 
            "Bye." 

            Sometimes I wonder if I'm in the right line of work. I know, I know 
-- what a crazy thing to be thinking. I mean, my parents knew from my infant 
reading that I'd grow up to have an aptitude for puzzle-solving, plus superior 
powers of observation. They made sure I had every opportunity to fulfill my 
potentials, and when I had my sooth read for myself at eighteen, it was obvious 
that this would be a perfect job for me to pursue. And yet, still, I have my 
doubts. I just don't feel like a cop sometimes. 
            But a soothsaying can't be wrong: almost every human trait has a 
genetic basis -- gullibility, mean-spiritedness, a goofy sense of humor, the 
urge to collect things, talents for various sports, every specific sexual 
predilection (according to my own sooth, my tastes ran to group sex with Asian 
women -- so far, I'd yet to find an opportunity to test that empirically). 
            Of course, when Mendelia started up, we didn't yet know what each 
gene and gene combo did. Even today, the SG is still adding new interpretations 
to the list. Still, I sometimes wonder how people in other parts of Free Space 
get along without soothsayers -- stumbling through life, looking for the right 
job; sometimes completely unaware of talents they possess; failing to know what 
specific things they should do to take care of their health. Oh, sure, you can 
get a genetic reading anywhere -- even down on Earth. But they're only mandatory 
here. 
            And my mandatory readings said I'd make a good cop. But, I have to 
admit, sometimes I'm not so sure ... 

            Rebecca Connolly was at home when I got there. On Earth, a family 
with the kind of money the Hissock-Connolly union had would own a mansion. Space 
is at a premium aboard a habitat, but their living room was big enough that its 
floor showed a hint of curvature. The art on the walls included originals by 
both Grant Wood and Bob Eggleton. There was no doubt they were loaded -- making 
it all the harder to believe they'd done in Uncle Skye for his money. 
            Rebecca Connolly was a gorgeous woman. According to the press 
reports I'd read, she was forty-four, but she looked twenty years younger. Gene 
therapy might be impossible here, but anyone who could afford it could have 
plastic surgery. Her hair was copper-colored, and her eyes an unnatural violet. 
"Hello, Detective Korsakov," she said. "My husband told me you were likely to 
stop by." She shook her head. "Poor Skye. Such a darling man." 
            I tilted my head. She was the first of Skye's relations to actually 
say something nice about him as a person -- which, after all, could just be a 
clumsy attempt to deflect suspicion from her. "You knew Skye well?" 
            "No -- to be honest, no. He and Rodger weren't that close. Funny 
thing, that. Skye used to come by the house frequently when we first got married 
-- he was Rodger's best man, did he tell you that? But when Glen was born, well, 
he stopped coming around as much. I dunno -- maybe he didn't like kids; he never 
had any of his own. Anyway, he really hasn't been a big part of our lives for, 
oh, eighteen years now." 
            "But Rodger's fingerprints were accepted by Skye's lock." 
            "Oh, yes. Rodger owns the unit Skye has his current offices in." 
            "I hate to ask you this, but --" 
            "I'm on the Board of Directors of TenthGen Computing, Detective. We 
were having a shareholders' meeting this morning. Something like eight hundred 
people saw me there." 
            I asked more questions, but didn't get any closer to identifying 
Rodger Hissock's motive. And so I decided to cheat -- as I said, sometimes I do 
wonder if I'm in the right kind of job. "Thanks for your help, Ms. Connolly. I 
don't want to take up any more of your time, but can I use your bathroom before 
I go?" 
            She smiled. "Of course. There's one down the hall, and one 
upstairs." 
            The upstairs one sounded more promising for my purposes. I went up 
to it, and the door closed behind me. I really did need to go, but first I 
pulled out my forensic scanner and started looking for specimens. Razors and 
combs were excellent places to find DNA samples; so were towels, if the user 
rubbed vigorously enough. Best of all, though, were toothbrushes. I scanned 
everything, but something was amiss. According to the scanner, there was DNA 
present from one woman -- the XX chromosome pair made the gender clear. And 
there was DNA from one man. But three males lived in this house: father Rodger, 
elder son Glen, and younger son Billy. 
            Perhaps this bathroom was used only by the parents, in which case 
I'd blown it -- I'd hardly get a chance to check out the other bathroom. But no 
-- there were four sets of towels, four toothbrushes, and there, on the edge of 
the tub, a toy aquashuttle ... precisely the kind an eight-year-old boy would 
play with. 
            Curious. Four people obviously used this john, but only two had left 
any genetic traces. And that made no sense -- I mean, sure, I hardly ever washed 
when I was eight like Billy, but no one can use a washroom day in and day out 
without leaving some DNA behind. 
            I relieved myself, the toilet autoflushed, and I went downstairs, 
thanked Ms. Connolly again, and left. 

            Like I said, I was cheating -- making me wonder again whether I 
really was cut out for a career in law enforcement. Even though it was a 
violation of civil rights, I took the male DNA sample I'd found in the 
Hissock-Connolly bathroom to Dana Rundstedt, who read its sooth for me. 
            I was amazed by the results. If I hadn't cheated, I might never have 
figured it out -- it was a damn-near perfect crime. 
            But it all fit, after seeing what was in the male DNA. 
            The fact that of the surviving Hissocks, only Rodger apparently had 
free access to Skye's inner office. 
            The fact that Rodger's blaster was the murder weapon. 
            The fact that there were apparently only two people using the 
bathroom. 
            The fact that Skye hated confrontation. 
            The fact that the Hissock-Connolly family had a lot of money they 
wanted to pass on to the next generation. 
            The fact that young Glen looked just like his dad, but was subdued 
and reserved. 
            The fact that Glen had gone to a different soothsayer. 
            The fact that Rodger's taste in receptionists was ... unusual. 
            The pieces all fit -- that part of my sooth, at least, must have 
been read correctly; I was good at puzzling things out. But I was still amazed 
by how elegant it was. 
            Ray Chen would sort out the legalities; he was an expert at that 
kind of thing. He'd find a way to smooth over my unauthorized soothsaying before 
we brought this to trial. 
            I got in a cab and headed off to Wheel Three to confront the killer. 

            "Hold it right there," I said, coming down the long, gently curving 
corridor at Francis Crick. "You're under arrest." 
            Glen Hissock stopped dead in his tracks. "What for?" 
            I looked around, then drew Glen into an empty classroom. "For the 
murder of your uncle, Skye Hissock. Or should I say, for the murder of your 
brother? The semantics are a bit tricky." 
            "I don't know what you're talking about," said Glen, in that 
subdued, nervous voice of his. 
            I shook my head. Soothsayer Skye had deserved punishment, and his 
brother Rodger was guilty of a heinous crime -- in fact, a crime Mendelian 
society considered every bit as bad as murder. But I couldn't let Glen get away 
with it. "I'm sorry for what happened to you," I said. The mental scars no doubt 
explained his sullen, withdrawn manner. 
            He glared at me. "Like that makes it better." 
            "When did it start?" 
            He was quiet for a time, then gave a little shrug, as if realizing 
there was no point in pretending any longer. "When I was twelve -- as soon as I 
entered puberty. Not every night, you understand. But often enough." He paused, 
then: "How'd you figure it out?" 
            I decided to tell him the truth. "There are only two different sets 
of DNA in your house -- one female, as you'd expect, and just one male." 
            Glen said nothing. 
            "I had the male DNA read. I was looking for a trait that might have 
provided a motive for your father. You know what I found." 
            Glen was still silent. 
            "When your dad's sooth was read just after birth, maybe his parents 
were told that he was sterile. Certainly the proof is there, in his DNA: an 
inability to produce viable sperm." I paused, remembering the details Rundstedt 
had explained to me. "But the soothsayer back then couldn't have known the 
effect of having the variant form of gene ABL-419d, with over a hundred T-A-T 
repeats. That variation's function hadn't been identified that long ago. But it 
was known by the time Rodger turned eighteen, by the time he went to see his big 
brother Skye, by the time Skye gave him his adult soothsaying." I paused. "But 
Uncle Skye hated confrontation, didn't he?" 
            Glen was motionless, a statue. 
            "And so Skye lied to your dad. Oh, he told him about his sterility, 
all right, but he figured there was no point in getting into an argument about 
what that variant gene meant." 
            Glen looked at the ground. When at last he did speak, his voice was 
bitter. "I had thought Dad knew. I confronted him -- Christ sakes, Dad, if you 
knew you had a gene for incestuous pedophilia, why the hell didn't you seek 
counseling? Why the hell did you have kids?" 
            "But your father didn't know, did he?" 
            Glen shook his head. "That bastard Uncle Skye hadn't told him." 
            "In fairness," I said, "Skye probably figured that since your father 
couldn't have kids, the problem would never come up. But your dad made a lot of 
money, and wanted it to pass to an heir. And since he couldn't have an heir the 
normal way ..." 
            Glen's voice was full of disgust. "Since he couldn't have an heir 
the normal way, he had one made." 
            I looked the boy up and down. I'd never met a clone before. Glen 
really was the spitting image of the old man -- a chip off the old block. But 
like any dynasty, the Hissock-Connolly clan wanted not just an heir, but an heir 
and a spare. Little Billy, ten years younger than Glen, was likewise an exact 
genetic duplicate of Rodger Hissock, produced from Rodger's DNA placed into one 
of Rebecca's eggs. All three Hissock males had indeed left DNA in that bathroom 
-- exactly identical DNA. 
            "Have you always known you were a clone?" I asked. 
            Glen shook his head. "I only just found out. Before I went for my 
adult soothsaying, I wanted to see the report my parents had gotten when I was 
born. But none existed -- my dad had decided to save some money. He didn't need 
a new report done, he figured; my sooth would be identical to his, after all. 
When I went to get my sooth read and found that I was sterile, well, it all fell 
into place in my mind." 
            "And so you took your father's blaster, and, since your fingerprints 
are essentially the same as his ..." 
            Glen nodded slowly. His voice was low and bitter. "Dad never knew in 
advance what was wrong with him -- never had a chance to get help. Uncle Skye 
never told him. Even after Dad had himself cloned, Skye never spoke up." He 
looked at me, fury in his cold gray eyes. "It doesn't work, dammit -- our whole 
way of life doesn't work if a soothsayer doesn't tell the truth. You can't play 
the hand you're dealt if you don't know what cards you've got. Skye deserved to 
die." 
            "And you framed your dad for it. You wanted to punish him, too." 
            Glen shook his head. "You don't understand, man. You can't 
understand." 
            "Try me." 
            "I didn't want to punish Dad -- I wanted to protect Billy. Dad can 
afford the best damn lawyer in Mendelia. Oh, he'll be found guilty, sure, but he 
won't get life. His lawyer will cut it down to the minimum mandatory sentence 
for murder, which is --" 
            "Ten years," I said, realization dawning. "In ten years, Billy will 
be an adult -- and out of danger from Rodger." 
            Glen nodded once. 
            "But Rodger could have told the truth at any time -- revealed that 
you were a clone of him. If he'd done that, he would have gotten off, and 
suspicion would have fallen on you. How did you know he wasn't going to speak 
up?" 
            Glen sounded a lot older than his eighteen years. "If Dad exposed 
me, I'd expose him -- and the penalty for child molestation is also a minimum 
ten years, so he'd be doing the time anyway." He looked directly at me. "Except 
being a murderer gets you left alone in jail, and being a pedophile gets you 
wrecked up." 
            I nodded, led him outside, and hailed a robocab. 
            Mendelia is a great place to live, honest. 
            And, hell, I did solve the crime, didn't I? Meaning I am a good 
detective. So I guess my soothsayer didn't lie to me. 
            At least -- at least I hope not ... 
            I had a sudden cold feeling that the SG would stop footing the bill 
long before this case could come to public trial. 

THE END

Further Reading: 
    A few notes about the science in this story, for those who might be 
    interested 
    Information about this story's nomination for the Hugo Award 
    Information about this story's nomination for the Crime Writers of Canada's 
    Arthur Ellis Award 
    Other short stories by Robert J. Sawyer 
    Information about Rob's novel Frameshift, a current nominee for the Hugo 
    Award for Best Novel of the Year 
    A profile of Rob from Tangent concentrating on his short-fiction career 
Back to the Robert J. Sawyer main page (www.sfwriter.com)