Help | Home » Theravada Text Archives » Contemporary Writers » Thanissaro Bhikkhu » Buddhist Monastic Code II

### Chapter Four

## Food

[ Previous Chapter | Table of Contents | Next Chapter ]

The three main classes of food -- staple foods, non-staple foods, and juice drinks -- have already been discussed in Volume One under the Food Chapter of the pacittiya rules. The question of making fruit allowable has been discussed under Pc 11. Here we will discuss aspects of the topic of food not covered in those passages.

Cooking & storing foods. One may not consume food stored indoors, cooked indoors, or cooked by oneself. There is a separate offense for each of these actions. Thus, if one consumes food stored indoors that one has cooked oneself, one incurs two dukkatas. According to the Commentary, "indoors" here means in an akappiya-kuti (a building that has not been designated as a food storage place) that would count as a "same lodging" with a bhikkhu under Pc 5 & 6. "Stored" means kept overnight, even if the food has not been formally offered. (Pc 38 imposes a pacittiya on eating food kept overnight after it has been formally offered, regardless of where it has been kept.) Food stored in a food storage place (kappiya-kuti -- see Chapter 7) doesn't count as stored indoors. A lay person's residence automatically counts as a kappiya-kuti, so a bhikkhu staying in such a place would be able to eat food that the lay person had stored and cooked there. These storing and cooking prohibitions apply only to staple foods, non-staple foods, and juice drinks, and not to medicines and tonics. However, if a medicine or tonic stored indoors is later mixed with food that has been kept in a kappiya-kuti, the resulting mixture counts as food stored indoors. If there is no kappiya-kuti, one may give food to an unordained person, bestowing ownership on him, and then properly re-accept it at a later date.

The Canon contains an allowance, however, that a bhikkhu may reheat food that has already been cooked by another.

The Mendaka allowance (Mv.VI.34.21) for gathering provisions for a journey is discussed under Pc 39.

Eating. A bhikkhu should not eat from the same dish or drink from the same beaker with anyone else at all, lay or ordained. The Commentary adds here, however, that if Bhikkhu X takes fruit from a dish and goes away, Bhikkhu Y may then take food from the same dish. After Bhikkhu Y goes away, Bhikkhu X may then come back for more. In other words, the prohibition is against using the same dish, etc., in the presence of another person who is also using it.

There is also a prohibition against eating from a food hamper (made of metal or wood, says the Commentary), which is apparently the raised, covered tray that was once used by Asian royalty and therefore considered a luxury. A bhikkhu who is ill, however, may eat from a raised tray. The Commentary says that this allowance extends to trays made of wicker ware or wood.

A bhikkhu who regurgitates his food is allowed to swallow it again as long as it has not come out of his mouth. The Commentary defines "out of his mouth" as meaning sticking in the mouth. In other words, when regurgitated food comes into the mouth, one may swallow it if it flows back down the throat, but not if it stays in the mouth. The Commentary here is interpreting mukha-dvara, literally the door of the face, as the larynx, and not the opening of the lips. Under Pc 40 we argued against this interpretation, and there is further evidence from M.140 that this interpretation should not stand. There, the space property in the body is divided into various parts, two of which are the mukha-dvara and the space "whereby what has been eaten, drunk, consumed, and savored gets swallowed." The larynx belongs to the second space; this leaves the mouth for the first. The awkwardness of the Commentary's interpretation here is yet another argument against taking mukha-dvara to mean larynx -- why food stuck in the mouth would be counted as outside the larynx but food that doesn't get stuck would not, is hard to explain. A more reasonable interpretation would be the common-sense one: regurgitated food may be swallowed again, even if it gets stuck in the mouth, but not if brought out of the mouth.

Famine allowances. The following actions, normally not allowed, are allowable during a famine: one may eat what has been stored indoors, cooked indoors, and cooked by oneself. If there is non-staple fruit and there is no one to make it allowable, one may pick it up and carry it away. If one meets an unordained person who can make it allowable, one may put the fruit on the ground and then consume it after having formally received it from that person. If one has eaten and turned down an offer of further food, one may still consume food that has not been made "left-over" (see Pc 35) if it was brought back from where the meal was, if it was formally accepted before the meal, or if it is food that has grown in the woods or in a lotus pond -- apparently these last two were places where people would go foraging during a famine.

Garlic. There is a prohibition against eating garlic unless one is ill. According to the Commentary, "ill" here means any illness for which garlic is a cure. According to current medical knowledge, this would include high blood cholesterol. Although Asian food often contains garlic as an ingredient, none of the texts mention the use of garlic mixed in with food. Perhaps it is allowable on the grounds of being a digestive aid. An alternative interpretation, accepted by many Communities, is that the original prohibition is against eating garlic by itself. Following this interpretation, garlic mixed with other ingredients would be allowable even when one is not ill.

Green gram. Although there are cases where green gram, even when cooked, may sprout, a bhikkhu is allowed to consume as much cooked green gram as he likes.

## Rules

"I allow anything falling while being presented to be picked up by oneself and eaten. Why is that? Because it has been relinquished by the benefactors." -- Cv.V.26

"One should not consume human flesh. Whoever should do so: a grave offense. And one should not consume meat without having reflected on it (on what it is). Whoever should do so: an offense of wrong doing." -- Mv.VI.23.9

"One should not consume elephant flesh ... horse flesh ... dog flesh ... snake flesh [C: Includes all long, footless beings] ... lion flesh ... tiger flesh ... leopard flesh ... bear flesh ... hyena flesh. Whoever should do so: an offense of wrong doing." -- Mv.VI.23.10-15

"One should not knowingly consume meat killed on purpose (for a bhikkhu). Whoever should consume it: an offense of wrong doing. I allow seafood and meat that is pure in three respects: one has not seen, heard, or suspected (that it was killed on purpose for a bhikkhu)." -- Mv.VI.31.14

"I allow all fruit that is non-staple." -- Mv.VI.38

"A mango is not to be consumed. Whoever should consume one: an offense of wrong doing." -- Cv.V.5.1 (This rule was later repealed by the rules at Cv.V.5.2)

"I allow mango peels." "I allow that fruit made allowable for contemplatives in any of five ways be consumed: damaged by fire, damaged by a knife, damaged by a fingernail, seedless, or with the seeds removed. I allow that fruit made allowable for contemplatives in any of these five ways be consumed." -- Cv.V.5.2

"I allow that fruit that has not been made allowable be consumed if it is without seeds, or if the seeds are discharged." -- Mv.VI.21

"Although green gram, even when cooked, sprouts, I allow that green gram be consumed as much as you like (§)." -- Mv.VI.16.2

"I allow conjey and honey-lumps (syrup sweets)." -- Mv.VI.24.7

"When invited to a certain place, one should not consume the eating-conjey of another (donor). Whoever should consume it should be dealt with in accordance with the rule (Pc 33)." -- Mv.VI.25.7

"I allow the five products of a cow: milk, curds, buttermilk, butter, ghee." -- Mv.VI.34.21

"I allow eight juice drinks: mango juice drink, jambolan juice drink, seed-banana juice drink, seedless banana juice drink, masang (Bassia pierrei) juice drink, grape juice drink, lotus root juice drink, maprang (Bouea burmanica (Anacardiaceae)) juice drink. I allow all fruit juice except for the juice of grain. I allow all leaf-juice except for the juice of cooked (§) vegetables. I allow all flower juice except for the juice of masang flowers. I allow fresh sugar cane juice." -- Mv.VI.35.6

"I allow all vegetables and all non-staple foods made with flour." -- Mv.VI.36.8

"Whatever I have not objected to, saying, 'This is not allowable,' if it fits in with what is not allowable, if it goes against what is allowable, this is not allowable for you. Whatever I have not objected to, saying, 'This is not allowable,' if it fits in with what is allowable, if it goes against what is not allowable, this is allowable for you. And whatever I have not permitted, saying, 'This is allowable,' if it fits in with what is not allowable, if it goes against what is allowable, this is not allowable for you. And whatever I have not permitted, saying, 'This is allowable,' if it fits in with what is allowable, if it goes against what is not allowable, this is allowable for you." -- Mv.VI.40.1

"Garlic should not be eaten. Whoever should eat it: an offense of wrong doing." -- Cv.V.34.1

"I allow that garlic be eaten in the event of illness." -- Cv.V.34.2

#### Cooking & Storing

"One should not consume what is stored (§) indoors (in one's dwelling), cooked indoors, or cooked by oneself." -- Mv.VI.17.3

"I allow reheating." -- Mv.VI.17.6

"There are badland roads with little water, little food. It is not easy to go along them with provisions for a journey. I allow that provisions for a journey be sought out: husked rice by one who has need of husked rice, green-gram by one who has need of green gram, beans by one who has need of beans, salt by one who has need of salt; sugar-patties by one who has need of sugar-patties, oil by one who has need of oil, ghee by one who has need of ghee." -- Mv.VI.34.21

#### Eating

"One should not eat from the same dish (with another person) (or) drink from the same beaker... Whoever should do so: an offense of wrong doing." -- Cv.V.19.2

"One should not eat from a food hamper (§). Whoever should do so: an offense of wrong doing" ... (A sick bhikkhu couldn't hold his bowl in his hand) "I allow a raised tray." -- Cv.V.19.1

"I allow ruminating for a ruminator. But one should not take in (ingest) anything brought outside of the mouth. Whoever should do so is to be dealt with according to the rule (Pc 37)." -- Cv.V.25

#### Famine Allowances

"I allow storing indoors ... I allow cooking indoors ... I allow that one cook for oneself ... I allow what is stored indoors, cooked indoors, and cooked by oneself." -- Mv.VI.17.7

"I allow that where one sees non-staple fruit, and there is no one to make it allowable, having picked it up and carried it away, having seen someone to make it allowable, having placed it on the ground, having formally received it, one may consume it. I allow that one formally accept what one has picked up." -- Mv.VI.17.9

"I allow that, having eaten and been satisfied, one may consume what has not been made left over if it is brought back from there (where the meal was)." -- Mv.VI.18.4

"I allow that, having eaten and been satisfied, one may consume what has not been made left over if it was formally accepted before the meal." -- Mv.VI.19.2

"I allow that, having eaten and been satisfied, one may consume what has not been made left over if it grows in the woods, if it grows in a lotus pond." -- Mv.VI.20.4

"Those things that were allowed by me for the bhikkhus when food was scarce, crops bad, and almsfood difficult to obtain: what was stored indoors, cooked indoors, cooked by oneself, accepting formally what was picked up; what was taken back from there; what was formally accepted before the meal; what grows in the woods; what grows in a lotus pond: from this day forward I rescind them. One should not consume what is stored indoors, cooked indoors, cooked by oneself; or what was formally accepted after having been picked up: Whoever should consume it: an offense of wrong doing. Nor should one, having eaten and been satisfied, consume food that is not left over if it is brought back from there (the place where the meal was offered), if it was formally accepted before the meal, if it grows in the woods or a lotus pond. Whoever should consume these is to be dealt with in accordance with the rule (Pc 35)." -- Mv.VI.32.2

"Day-long food (juice drinks) mixed with time-period (morning) food is allowable in the time period, but not outside of the time period. Seven-day medicine (tonics) mixed with time-period food is allowable in the time period, but not outside of the time period. Life-long medicine mixed with time-period food is allowable in the time period, but not outside of the time period. Seven-day medicine mixed with day-long food is allowable during the day, but not when the day has passed. Life-long medicine mixed with day-long food is allowable during the day, but not when the day has passed. Life-long medicine mixed with seven-day medicine is allowable during the seven days, but not when the seven days have passed." -- Mv.VI.40.3

#### From the Second Council

(1) Is the permission for a salt horn permissible?
What is the permission for a salt horn?
"It is permissible to carry a salt horn, (thinking,) 'I will enjoy whatever is unsalted.'"
That is not permissible.
Where is it objected to?
In Savatthi, in the Sutta Vibhanga (Pc 38).
What offense is committed?
A pacittiya for stored-up food.

(2) Is the permission for two fingerbreadths permissible?
What is the permission for two fingerbreadths?
"When the sun's shadow has passed two fingerbreadths into the 'wrong time,' it is still permissible to eat food."
That is not permissible.
Where is it objected to?
In Rajagaha, in the Sutta Vibhanga (Pc 37).
What offense is committed?
A pacittiya for eating in the wrong time.

(3) Is the permission for among villages permissible?
What is the permission for among villages?
"Having eaten and turned down an offer of further food, it is permissible for one who thinks, 'I will now go among villages/into the village,' to eat food that is not left over."
That is not permissible.
Where is it objected to?
In Savatthi, in the Sutta Vibhanga (Pc 35).
What offense is committed?
A pacittiya for eating what is not left over.

(7) Is the permission for unchurned buttermilk permissible?
What is the permission for unchurned buttermilk?
"Having eaten and turned down an offer of further food, it is permissible to drink milk that is not left over that has passed the state of being milk but not yet arrived at the state of being curds."
That is not permissible.
Where is it objected to?
In Savatthi, in the Sutta Vibhanga (Pc 35).
What offense is committed?
A pacittiya for eating what is not left over.

(8) Is the permission for unfermented toddy permissible?
What is the permission for unfermented toddy?
"It is permissible to drink alcohol that has not fermented and has not yet arrived at the state of being strong drink."
That is not permissible.
Where is it objected to?
In Kosambi, in the Sutta Vibhanga (Pc 51).
What offense is committed?
A pacittiya for drinking alcohol and fermented liquor.

> -- Cv. XI.2.8

[ Previous Chapter | Table of Contents | Next Chapter ]

Revised: Thu 14 March 2002